Spec-by-spec

Head to head

Contenders from Countertop Ice Makers, every metric lined up. The winning value in each row is outlined.

Price

Check price on Amazon →

Rating

★★★★★

Category rank

Ice Quality

Soft chewable nugget

Soft nugget/pebble ice

Output Rate

26 lbs/day, 20 min first ice

26 lbs/day, ~15–20 min first ice

Bin Capacity

2.6 lb bin, 1.1 L tank

1.3 lb bin, 0.3 gal tank

Noise Level

Moderate-quiet operation

Moderate hum

Convenience

Manual cleaning only

Footprint

Compact 14.8" W

Compact, fits tight spaces

Value

Strong output/reliability for $94

Good output & brand for price

Verdict

Best value compact nugget ice maker

Budget-friendly Frigidaire nugget maker

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission